A grassy slope with scattered conifers in the foreground overlooking forested ridges and a partly snow-covered mountain peak under a cloudy sky.Skip the search

Signs of a cracked heat exchanger in Colorado

Answer a few questions instead of calling shop after shop.

A cracked heat exchanger isn't something you can check by looking at the furnace running. You might notice soot around the burner, a smell when the blower kicks on, or a carbon monoxide alarm that goes off and won't tell you why. By the time you're searching for this, something about your furnace has already made you uneasy.

That's the right instinct. A furnace this many winters into service, especially one that's been running hard across Colorado's cold stretch, deserves a look from someone who knows what a cracked exchanger actually does to a flame and to the air moving through your ducts.

Finding that person is usually its own chore. You'd normally be searching for furnace repair companies, calling a few, describing the smell or the soot or the alarm to each one, then waiting to see who calls back first and who can actually get to your house this week. Some of them will want to sell you a new furnace before anyone has looked at the old one.

This page skips that part. You tell it what you're seeing, and it connects you with one contractor who works on furnaces like yours in Colorado, not a list of five companies competing for your callback. Someone who checks exchangers every winter and knows the difference between a furnace that needs a part replaced and one that needs to be shut off until it's fixed.

You still get a real diagnosis, a real repair, and a real conversation about what's wrong. What goes away is the part where you're the one doing the legwork to find someone qualified to have that conversation with. Below, the specific signs to check before that visit, and what they tell you about what's happening inside the furnace.

A cracked heat exchanger usually shows up as a change in the furnace, not a clear warning. You might notice the flame looks different, wavering or flaring instead of burning steady blue, or the burner box has soot where it didn't before. Some homeowners catch a smell, almost formaldehyde-like, right when the blower starts. Others never smell or see anything, and the first sign is a carbon monoxide alarm going off. This happens because the metal inside the exchanger expands and contracts every time your furnace cycles on and off, all winter, and after enough years it can split along a seam you can't see without taking the furnace apart. A furnace that runs October through April in Colorado puts a lot of cycles on that metal. If you're seeing any of this, the furnace needs to be shut off and looked at before you run it again.

A smiling woman with long dark hair in a gray sweater sits at a white stone counter with a glass of white wine, with a kitchen, fireplace and sofa visible behind her.
A smiling woman with dark hair in a cream sweater sits at a marble table with a glass of red wine, with a lit lamp, sofa, fireplace and kitchen counter behind her.
A woman in a cream sweater laughs while seated at a marble countertop with a glass of red wine, with a dimly lit living room and sofa behind her.
A woman in a beige turtleneck sweater with her hair up sits laughing and looking to the side at a white marble table with a glass of red wine, in a dimly lit interior with a lamp and seating area behind her.

Heats and cools on one gas line

A furnace with a cracked heat exchanger can still push warm air through the house, which is why the leak goes unnoticed until someone catches the smell or the alarm.

Reach a local pro

One local contractor, not several

A tech who works on furnaces around Colorado every winter knows which models crack first and what to check before touching the burner box.

Reach a local pro

Is my furnace making me sick without warning

A headache that fades when you leave the house and comes back in the evening is worth paying attention to. So is a smell like formaldehyde near the furnace, or a pilot light that burns yellow instead of blue. Some households notice nothing at all until a carbon monoxide alarm sounds. Soot on the burner box or around the front panel is another sign, especially if it wasn't there last winter. None of these prove a crack by themselves, but together they mean the furnace is burning differently than it used to, and that's the thing to act on. A cracked heat exchanger can let carbon monoxide into the air you're breathing, which is why these signs matter more than most furnace trouble does.

A beige high-efficiency furnace stands on a concrete basement floor beside sheet-metal ductwork, with white PVC vent pipes and a gas line running along an insulated wood-framed wall.

Furnace running as it should

A steady blue flame, no soot on the burner box, no smell when the blower kicks on. The flue pipes carry exhaust straight outside and the air coming through your vents doesn't carry any odor with it. This is what a heat exchanger with no crack in it looks like day to day.

An older metal furnace with a louvered front panel stands against a concrete basement wall, connected to sheet-metal ductwork and a flue pipe, with copper and steel pipes running alongside.

Furnace showing a problem

Dust and age on the cabinet alone don't tell you much, but paired with a flame that flares or wavers, or soot where there wasn't any before, they're worth a second look. A furnace like this can still run and still heat the house, which is exactly why a crack goes unnoticed as long as it does.

Keep Running It or Get It Checked

Keep running it

  • A cracked heat exchanger doesn't always stop the furnace from heating, so the house can stay warm while the leak continues.
  • Carbon monoxide has no smell on its own, so you're relying on soot, an odor from something else burning, or an alarm to catch it.
  • The crack doesn't heal or stay the same size once it starts, and Colorado's winters mean the furnace runs long stretches at a time.
  • A furnace that's cycling on and off more than usual is stressing the same metal that's already compromised.
  • Waiting means more hours of exhaust mixing with the air moving through your ducts.

Get it inspected

  • A contractor can pull the burner assembly and look at the exchanger directly, which isn't something you can do from outside the cabinet.
  • A combustion analyzer checks for carbon monoxide in the flue gas, catching a leak before it shows up as a smell or an alarm.
  • If the exchanger is cracked, the furnace gets shut down on the spot rather than left running until parts arrive.
  • A local contractor who services furnaces through a Colorado winter has seen which models and ages tend to crack first.
  • One inspection gives you an answer, instead of guessing from a flame color or a smell that might be something else entirely.
A gray high-efficiency furnace with white PVC vent pipes stands on a concrete pad in a basement, beside sheet-metal ductwork, copper piping and a poured concrete wall with wood framing at left.
A furnace running clean sits on its pad with the flue pipe tight and the ductwork sound, nothing around the burner but metal.
A beige gas furnace in a basement with a metal flue pipe, galvanized sheet-metal ductwork to its left, and gas and water pipes along the concrete wall to its right.
An older furnace with a cracked exchanger can look just as ordinary, the flue still drawing, while the leak stays hidden inside the casing.
  1. Burner ignites inside the heat exchanger chamber and warms the metal walls.

  2. Metal expands with heat and a crack opens along a weak seam.

  3. Blower pulls house air across the cracked exchanger to heat it.

  4. Combustion gases leak through the crack into that same air stream.

A beige metal furnace with a louvered front panel stands on a concrete floor against a concrete wall, connected to galvanized sheet-metal ductwork and a metal pipe.
Before you get your furnace repair
A gray high-efficiency furnace stands on a concrete basement floor beside sheet-metal ductwork, with white PVC vent pipes and a black flexible line running up to exposed wood floor joists, next to a wood-framed post against a concrete wall.
After you get your furnace repair

Describe it once

A cracked exchanger isn't something to diagnose over the phone or wait out until spring. Once you suspect one, the furnace needs eyes on it, combustion testing equipment, and someone who knows what a Colorado winter does to a furnace that's been running flat out since October. Finding that person usually means searching around, calling a few companies, explaining the soot smell or the headaches that fade when you leave the house, then doing it again with the next company and comparing what each one quoted you. Handing the request off instead skips that part. It goes to one local contractor who works on furnaces like yours every heating season and knows which models in this area tend to crack first and where. You're not fielding calls from five different companies while your furnace sits there leaking exhaust into the air your blower is pushing through the house. You make one request and get one call back, and the furnace gets looked at properly by someone who already knows what to check.

A gray high-efficiency furnace in a basement with PVC vent pipes, sheet-metal ductwork, copper and insulated pipes, a water heater at left, and an unfinished wood-stud wall at right.

This furnace is doing what it's supposed to

Sitting on its pad, flue pipes running straight up and out, ductwork intact around it. A furnace built like this one draws combustion gas out through the PVC and keeps it away from the air the blower moves through the house.

An older beige furnace with louvered front panels stands on a concrete basement floor beside galvanized ductwork, metal and plastic pipes, exposed wood framing, and a cylindrical water heater at right.

This one has had a longer run

Galvanized ductwork, an older cabinet, flue pipes that have carried exhaust for a lot of winters already. Age alone doesn't crack a heat exchanger, but a furnace this old has gone through enough heating and cooling cycles that the metal has had time to fatigue.

Why does a crack form in the heat exchanger in the first place?

You keep hearing that heat exchangers crack, but nobody explains why metal inside a sealed furnace would split on its own. It helps to know what's actually happening in there every time the burner fires, especially with how hard a Colorado furnace runs once the cold sets in and stays on for hours at a stretch through the winter.

Repeated heating and cooling fatigues the metal until it splits

Every time the burner lights, the heat exchanger gets hot fast, then cools again once the thermostat is satisfied and the burner shuts off. That metal expands when it heats and contracts when it cools, over and over, heating cycle after heating cycle through a Colorado winter. Years of that movement fatigue the metal the same way bending a wire back and forth eventually snaps it. The crack opens where the metal is thinnest or where a weld already sits under stress, usually along a seam or a bend. A furnace that short cycles, firing on and off more often than it should, puts the exchanger through more of these swings and can bring the crack on sooner.

Gable end of a gray board-and-batten house with a thick layer of snow on the roof, surrounded by snow-covered conifer trees during falling snow.

Statewide, winter nights average 16°F, and that's the stretch where your furnace runs the longest, often most of the night without shutting off. A heat exchanger that's already cracked gets more cycles of expansion and contraction during a run like that, and the crack can widen. You might notice the furnace short cycling, or the burner flame acting up more on the coldest nights than it did in October. A furnace that seemed fine in fall can start showing signs once nights settle into the teens. Source: NOAA statewide averages.

NOAA nClimDiv 1991-2020 county normals weighted by homes

A smiling bearded man in a dark crewneck sweater sits at a dinner table with a lit candle, glasses of wine and water, and plates of food in the foreground, with a lamp, framed art and a potted plant behind him.
A woman with dark hair in a bun reclines on a gray sofa with her eyes closed and a slight smile, wrapped in a cream knit sweater and blanket, with an open book resting in the foreground and a lit lamp in the dim room behind.

Keep waiting to see if it gets worse, and you're the one cycling the air across a crack that opens a little further every cold night this furnace runs.

Get a contractor out to run a combustion test, and you know within an hour whether the exchanger is cracked or the furnace is fine to keep running.

Winter nights average 16°F statewide

Nights that cold mean your furnace is cycling on for hours at a stretch, not just kicking on here and there. A cracked exchanger gets that much more expansion and contraction to work with on a run like that, which is how a hairline crack turns into a bigger problem by February.

NOAA nClimDiv 1991-2020 county normals weighted by homes

A closed silver laptop and a white cup of coffee on a saucer sit on a wooden table in front of a wooden chair, a plain beige wall, a potted leafy plant and a window with greenery outside.

A change in the furnace is the sign, not a single clear alarm

Soot on the burner box, a smell when the blower kicks on, a flame that wavers instead of burning steady blue. None of these prove a cracked heat exchanger on their own, but together they're reason enough to get a combustion test done before another cold night on the Front Range or the Western Slope puts more hours on a furnace that's already leaking.

You don't have to figure out which of those signs matter most or track down who in your area actually tests for this. One contractor, local, licensed, and used to what a Colorado winter does to an aging furnace, can tell you within an hour whether the exchanger is cracked. That's one call instead of several, one person looking at your furnace instead of you explaining the same smell and the same flame to three different companies before you get a straight answer.

A gray upholstered sofa with a beige cushion and knit blanket beside a curtained window, with a white mug and a book on a dark wooden table in the foreground and a lit lamp in the background.
A dark gray high-efficiency furnace with two white vent pipes and connected sheet-metal ductwork stands in an unfinished basement with concrete walls, a support pole, and a small window.

No phone calls to make

Step 1 of 3: Equipment